Top-Rated Car Insurance Companies

Best Overall

Lowest Price

Best Claims Handling

Best for Bundling

Best for Safe Drivers

Best for Drivers with Accidents or Tickets on Record

Best for Uninsured Drivers

Best for Young Drivers

Our Ratings Methodology

The Car Insurance Guide team assigns ratings to the companies we feature in the following categories: pricing, bundling options, claims handling, suitability for safe drivers, young drivers, uninsured drivers, and drivers with accidents, tickets, or DUIs on record. Taking these ratings into account, we calculate an editorial rating for each company. With decades of experience and hours of in-depth research to back us up, our ratings accurately reflect the strengths and weaknesses of each auto insurance carrier. With these ratings, we hope to provide clear and helpful information on the factors that truly matter when it comes to picking your insurer.

Compare the Best Car Insurance Options

Please provide a valid zip